Calorie Tracking

MyFitnessPal vs Lose It in 2026: Which Is Better for Weight Loss?

Derek Clark Derek Clark ·
MyFitnessPal vs Lose It in 2026: Which Is Better for Weight Loss?

MyFitnessPal vs Lose It comes down to what you want from the app. MyFitnessPal is the better pick if you care about macros and device syncing, since its free tier still handles both. Lose It is the better pick if you mostly want a simple calorie budget and a friendly app that gets you logging fast. For weight loss specifically, neither one has an edge you can measure. The research says the app you’ll keep opening every day matters far more than which logo is on it.

Both apps have moved popular features behind their paywalls, so here’s what each free tier includes, what Premium costs (checked on each company’s own pages as of October 2026) and who should pick which.

MyFitnessPal vs Lose It at a glance

MyFitnessPal Lose It
Free tier includes Food and exercise logging, macros shown with goals set by percentage, partner app syncing, ads Calorie budget, food and exercise logging, weight loss plan, Apple Health and Apple Watch sync, ads
Premium price (US, list) $19.99/month or $79.99/year $79.99/year (in-app discounts are common)
Top tier Premium+ at $24.99/month or $99.99/year, adds a meal planner and grocery lists Lifetime at $299.99 one time
Barcode scanner Premium only (since October 2022) Moving to Premium; some free members still have it
Photo logging Meal Scan, Premium only Snap It, Premium only
Voice logging Premium Premium
Macro goals Percentages free, grams with Premium Premium
Food database (per App Store listing) 20.5 million plus foods 56 million plus items and recipes
Fitbit, Garmin and similar syncs Free Premium
App Store rating 4.7 from 2.4 million ratings 4.8 from 782,000 ratings

Ratings and database sizes come from the MyFitnessPal and Lose It App Store listings. Each company counts its database differently, so treat those numbers as marketing.

Who MyFitnessPal is for

MyFitnessPal is the default calorie counter for a reason. It connects with more than 40 fitness trackers, smartwatches and health apps, and its database includes restaurant dishes as well as packaged foods. Private equity firm Francisco Partners has owned it since buying it from Under Armour in 2020.

The free version is still genuinely usable. According to MyFitnessPal’s own plan comparison, free accounts can log food and exercise, create foods and recipes, view macronutrients, set calorie and macro goals by percentage, share a diary and link partner apps. That last part matters if you wear a Garmin or Fitbit, because those syncs don’t cost anything here.

What’s gone from free is the convenience. Barcode Scan has required Premium since October 1, 2022, and Meal Scan, voice logging, macro goals in grams, different goals by day and ad-free logging are all Premium too. So free MyFitnessPal means typing searches, with ads.

Price: Premium is $19.99 a month or $79.99 a year on MyFitnessPal’s website. Premium+ costs $24.99 a month or $99.99 a year and adds a weekly meal planner with more than 1,500 recipes, grocery lists and grocery delivery integration. The App Store also lists cheaper Premium plans (as low as $49.99 for a yearly option), so you may be offered a discount inside the app.

The catch: It’s busy. Years of stacked features make it feel crowded next to Lose It, and the newest headline feature (an AI Coach that answers questions about your diary) is for paying members on iOS only.

Who Lose It is for

Lose It (officially Lose It!) launched in 2008 and is built around one idea. Tell it your weight goal, it hands you a daily calorie budget, and you log against that number. Setup is quick and the interface is simpler than MyFitnessPal’s, so it’s a good fit if MyFitnessPal felt overwhelming.

The free tier (Lose It calls it Basic) covers calorie tracking, a personalized weight loss plan, community groups, and syncing with Apple Health. Connecting an Apple Watch to earn a calorie bonus for extra activity is free too.

Premium is where almost everything else lives. The App Store listing puts photo and voice logging, the barcode scanner, macro and nutrient tracking, intermittent fasting, meal planning and Fitbit, Garmin and Withings syncing on the paid side. Want to track protein, carbs and fat? You’re paying.

The barcode scanner is in an awkward spot. Lose It’s help center says it’s moving the barcode and nutrition label scanners to Premium and that some free members still have access during the transition. If your free account can scan today, don’t count on it lasting.

Price: Lose It’s membership and pricing page lists Premium at $79.99 a year and Lifetime at $299.99 one time (less if you’re already a Premium member). In practice you’ll probably pay less. Lose It says most users get discounted offers inside the app, and the App Store lists several lower Premium price points, including $39.99. You can also pay once to remove ads without buying Premium.

The catch: Free Lose It is calories only. And its help center claims Premium members lose three times as much weight as free members, which probably says more about who pays for a weight loss app than about what the money buys.

Photo and AI logging: Meal Scan vs Snap It

Both apps now let you point your camera at a plate, and both keep it behind Premium. MyFitnessPal’s Meal Scan suggests matching database entries for you to confirm. Lose It’s Snap It works the same way, finding likely matches and estimating serving sizes you can edit. Both also have voice logging, where you say what you ate and the app turns it into entries.

How good are they? A team at the NIH’s National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases tested the photo features of MyFitnessPal, Lose It, Cal AI and Appediet on 102 meals with precisely weighed ingredients. Across the four apps, estimates came in about 250 to 345 calories too low per meal on average, and MyFitnessPal and Lose It did better on higher-calorie meals than lower-calorie ones. Those results were presented at a July 2026 conference and haven’t been through full peer review, but the direction is hard to ignore. Treat a photo estimate as a first draft and fix the portion before saving. We dig into why in does photo calorie tracking work.

If photo logging is the main thing you want, a photo-first app is a third option. AI Calorie Tracker lets you log meals by photo or manually and estimates calories and macros, for $29.99 a year. For a wider look at that category, see our roundup of the best AI calorie trackers in 2026.

Disclosure: AI Calorie Tracker is made by the team behind this blog.

Which is more accurate, MyFitnessPal or Lose It?

Close enough that accuracy shouldn’t decide it. The most direct comparison is a 2018 University of Minnesota study in Public Health Nutrition. Researchers entered 30 one-day food records into five free apps, including both of these, and compared the results with research-grade nutrition software.

Calorie totals weren’t among the significant differences for either app. Both came in low on protein, fat, sodium and cholesterol. Lose It also ran low on sugars and saturated fat, so MyFitnessPal had slightly fewer misses. That study is eight years old and both databases have changed since, so don’t read much into the gap.

The bigger accuracy problem is user-submitted entries. Both databases include foods added by members, and one bad entry can throw off a day. Pick entries with full nutrition info and weigh foods now and then to keep portions honest. Our guide to how to track macros covers the habits that matter more than the app.

MyFitnessPal vs Lose It for weight loss

In a randomized trial in Annals of Internal Medicine, 212 primary care patients with a BMI of 25 or higher got usual care, and about half also got help downloading MyFitnessPal. After six months, weight change was minimal, with no real difference between groups (about 0.3 kg, under a pound). Most people liked the app. Their logins just dropped sharply after the first month.

That’s not a knock on MyFitnessPal, and there’s no reason to think Lose It is immune. The app isn’t what produces the weight loss. Consistent logging is. A systematic review of self-monitoring studies found a consistent link between self-monitoring and weight loss, even if the studies had real limitations.

So for weight loss, choose the app you’ll find least annoying on day 40. If MyFitnessPal’s clutter wears you down, Lose It’s simpler budget is the better weight loss app for you. If you want your Garmin steps, macros and recipes all in one place, MyFitnessPal is. And if you’re working out how big your deficit should be, start with what a calorie deficit actually is before you pick a goal.

Privacy: what to know about both apps

MyFitnessPal has the bigger history here. In March 2018, when Under Armour owned the app, it announced that about 150 million accounts had been compromised, exposing usernames, email addresses and encrypted passwords. If you had an account back then and reused that password anywhere, change it.

Today, both apps’ App Store privacy labels say some of your data may be used to track you across other companies’ apps and websites. Neither is a privacy-first app, so tell your iPhone to ask apps not to track you if that bothers you.

Which should you choose?

Choose MyFitnessPal if you want to see your macros without paying or you sync a Garmin or Fitbit.

Choose MyFitnessPal Premium+ if deciding what to cook is the hard part and you want meal plans and grocery lists built for you.

Choose Lose It if you want a clean calorie budget and you’re fine tracking calories only on the free tier.

Choose Lose It Premium if you’d use the scanner, photo and voice logging and macro goals, and you can catch one of its frequent discounts.

Still deciding between more than two apps? Our best macro tracking apps of 2026 compares MyFitnessPal and Lose It with Cronometer and MacroFactor.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Lose It better than MyFitnessPal?

For simplicity, yes. Lose It has a cleaner interface and a faster setup built around a daily calorie budget. MyFitnessPal is better for macros and device syncing, and its free tier does more, including macros and partner app links.

Is MyFitnessPal or Lose It better for weight loss?

Neither has a proven edge. In a randomized trial, giving people MyFitnessPal produced almost no weight change, largely because logins dropped off after a month. Consistent logging is what works, so pick the app you’ll keep using.

Is the MyFitnessPal barcode scanner free?

No. MyFitnessPal moved Barcode Scan to Premium on October 1, 2022. Lose It is making the same change, and its help center says some free members still have the scanner during the transition.

How much does Lose It Premium cost?

Lose It lists Premium at $79.99 a year as of October 2026, with a Lifetime option at $299.99. Discounted offers inside the app are common, and the App Store lists lower price points, including $39.99.

The bottom line

MyFitnessPal is the more capable app, and its free tier is more generous for anyone who cares about macros. Lose It is the friendlier app, and friendly is easier to stick with. Both charge about $80 a year at list price for the features most people want, and both discount often.

Try the free version of each for a week, then keep the one that felt less like homework. That’s the app that’ll help you lose weight.

AI Calorie Tracker

AI Calorie Tracker

Snap a photo. Get the calories.

Get on App Store
Derek Clark

Derek Clark

Co-founder of Vima Fitness. Building simple, privacy-focused fitness apps for iPhone and Apple Watch since 2011. Runner, cyclist, and firm believer that fitness apps shouldn't need a tutorial.

← Back to Blog